Comments on Viruswitch: The Problems of (the Greek) Wikipedia

I can't remember how I got this link. But it was i...

2006-03-13T12:16:00.000+02:00

I can't remember how I got this link. But it was in my dropdown list of sites that I had visited:

http://www.wikipedia-watch.org

Might be interesting to you. I think you should document your reasons (online) for leaving Wikipedia.

It really surprises me that they think its ok. Wik...

2006-03-02T23:28:00.000+02:00

It really surprises me that they think its ok. Wikipedia is generally not "beliebt" to the press. I used to wonder why they write so many negative things about it but now I know why.

I keep thinking ybout your post here and coming ba...

2006-03-02T09:02:00.000+02:00

I keep thinking ybout your post here and coming back to it, because it is so unbelievable to me that a source of information would be misused in this manner. I think you should collect more examples of this and submit it to a newspaper/magazine. I don't really have an overview of the German wikipedia to be able to judge what's there. It's considerably smaller than the English language version.

That doesn't fall under the definition of satire. ...

2006-03-01T14:58:00.000+02:00

That doesn't fall under the definition of satire. It falls under the definition of primitive trash. Something like that is an embarassment to the Wikipedia concept. Incidentally, humor and satire have no place in a reference work. This doesn't even meet the definition of humor for the Uncyclopedia, the Wikipedia parody you posted about.

It seems like now that people have discovered the Wikipedia, the group of dedicated and sincere people who started it off has been irretrievably dilluted.

ACtually there is no moderation in wikipedia as we...

2006-03-01T06:04:00.000+02:00

ACtually there is no moderation in wikipedia as we mean it. Anyone can write anything as you see, and that is especially valid for userpages. The reason I left the greek wikipedia is because I saw a userpage with an indian erotic painting of three people engaging in sex. I didnt mind the painting (even though one should take into consideration that there are many users from 11-13 and up years old who contribute a great deal). But what really bothered me was the comment under the picture:

"Genital Discussion: In the perverse country of India they do such disgusting acts."

Above this picture was one of friendly parrots used to indicate the right type of discussion. Well I didnt find that funny at all.

I posted in wiki saying that this comment is an insult to a great civilization such as the Indian one. But the majority of users believed this is satiric and it should stay there. Well, since that stays I go, because I am have too deep admiration for the culture, philosophy and people of India. Before that I wasnt aware that there is no moderation in wikipedia and that administrators are not there to delete offensive content. Now that I really know how it functions... no thanks.

Now I remember, there was an article aobut America...

2006-02-28T07:04:00.000+02:00

Now I remember, there was an article aobut American politicians tampering with Wikipedia content:

www.washingtonpost.com

These are excellent posts you found, and very prof...

2006-02-27T20:44:00.000+02:00

These are excellent posts you found, and very professionally written. I was aware of this negative aspect of Wikipedia, especially the using it for defamation, slander and misrepresenetations. I realized how open it was, but thought there was enough moderation in place to hold things in check.

The articles I've read have seemed to me to be objective and complete. But my impression that there are also very many trivial articles, things that dont really belong in an encyclopedia. That increases the content that has to be moderated and makes it more difficult to concentrate on the important articles.

I also heard about a somewhat mediocre author who listed himself in the Wikiedpia as a comic author on the level with Joseph Heller and John Kennedy Toole. Which he ain't.

One day the system of wiki will inevitably change ...

2006-02-27T07:56:00.000+02:00

One day the system of wiki will inevitably change or just collapse.

I shouldnt have posted but I just had to let it out... Looking at my list... its soooo long.

Once the legal system holds people accountable fis...

2006-02-27T07:47:00.000+02:00

Once the legal system holds people accountable fiscally for slander than one will be more careful what one writes on Wikipedia.

Nice to see you posting again my dear.